VOLUME 104
ISSUE 09
The Student Movement

Arts & Entertainment

Liam Payne and the Legacy of One Direction

Audrey Lim


Photo by Eva Rinaldi

On Oct. 16, singer and former One Direction member Liam Payne passed away at 31 years of age. After attending his former bandmate Niall Horan’s concert on Oct. 2 in Argentina, Liam stayed at the Casa Sur Hotel, where he reportedly fell from his third-floor bedroom balcony. Evidence suggests he was likely alone, and the autopsy report indicated he had multiple drugs in his system. 

Liam Payne was best known as a member of One Direction, the formative British boy band that defined the 2010s pop music sphere. Along with his bandmates Louis Tomlinson, Zayn Malik, Harry Styles and Niall Horan, Liam’s career started with his audition on the competition show “The X Factor” (UK).

One Direction was indisputably the biggest boy band of the 2010s and extended in global prominence in conjunction with the rise of YouTube, Twitter and other social media platforms. These growing platforms provided an accessible space to facilitate early parasocial relationships—one-sided, intense bonds that make fans feel closely attached to celebrities they have never interacted with. On social media, where One Direction could post tour vlogs and behind-the-scenes videos and members could share about their personal lives and reply to fans, One Direction fans’ parasocial relationships thrived. While not every girl in the 2010s was a fan of One Direction, those who were could become very devoted to the band and their favorite member through these new avenues for promoting parasocial relationships. 

However, in January 2016, much to their fans’ dismay, One Direction decided to break up following Zayn’s departure a year earlier. After their split, each member went on to release solo music with varied success. Unfortunately, Liam’s solo career was one of the least successful of the band, and according to K-Data, his popularity even during his time in One Direction was overshadowed relative to the other members.

The death of Liam Payne hit grieving fans hard, but it also marked a nostalgic end to an era where the boys made video diaries on YouTube, guest starred on “iCarly” and made a prevailing cover of Wheatus’ “Teenage Dirtbag.” According to some of the students on our campus, this loss has elucidated how influential One Direction was to Gen Z’s childhood. 

Katlin Nelson (senior, music education) reflects on how formative One Direction was in developing her love of music, as they were the first artists she discovered on her own and her first concert when she was 12 years old. 

“It’s such a tragedy to see someone so beloved in our generation pass like this,” she says. “I hope we can learn from this the importance of checking in on the people in our lives and helping them the best we can. I will never forget the memories I have of One Direction and how much joy they brought to people like me.” 

Similarly, Jessica Ruvalcaba (junior, data science) parallels the impact of Liam’s death with The Beatles. Regarding the role of his substance use in his death, she talks about the prevalence of drugs and alcohol surrounding celebrity deaths, saying, “It’s very scary and makes you wonder who’s going to be next.” 

Xina Sanchez (senior, religion) reminisces on her long journey with One Direction, from watching them audition individually on “The X Factor” to forming a band of brothers who rose to international fame. She mentions how she vividly remembers introducing One Direction to her Pathfinder friends, and the lyrics in songs such as “Little Things” and “What Makes You Beautiful” boosted their confidence during an age when they began to struggle with budding insecurities. 

“I didn’t have sisters,” Xina said, “but One Direction brought us to bond in girlhood and sisterhood. They impacted my youth a lot.” 

While hearing of the death of Liam Payne was “devastating” to her, it also brought back happy childhood memories of friendship.

Liam Payne was a figure who had a significant influence on 2010s pop culture and music. He was also a man who brought compassion and warm companionship to his bandmates and loved ones based on their tribute posts. While Liam experienced the splendors of global fame through One Direction, he also suffered through the pitfalls of pop stardom and a diminishing career trajectory. Perhaps blame can be placed upon parasocial relationships, where a celebrity can be venerated in one moment and canceled in the next when contradictory information is revealed that doesn’t match fans’ idealized image of them. 

As a representative of many of Generation Z’s childhoods, Liam Payne’s memory and legacy will forever be carried with us. May he rest in peace.


The Student Movement is the official student newspaper of Andrews University. Opinions expressed in the Student Movement are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the editors, Andrews University or the Seventh-day Adventist church.